Inexcuseable Roster Management

I have a post that I'm working on that will provide additional recapiness from last night's loss to Chicago. There is a discussion about Nolan Yonkman, and about what really stood out for Lane Lambert about the loss, as well as some more great photo work from Chris Jerina. But that post has to be put on hold for a minute.

I've spent the last 24 hours completely befuddled. I've been saying on these very webpages that I expect Nashville to recall another Admirals player for tonight's game against Anaheim. At this hour, it appears that I am wrong. Now - I don't mind being wrong. I don't like it...but it happens on occassion. This case, however, defies all logic to me.

The Nashville Predators have 6 defensemen and 12 forwards with them in California. That's it. 18 skaters. What happens if one of those skaters suddenly becomes unavailable? The game is still 10 hours away (at the time I am writing this). A LOT can happen in 10 hours.

For instance:

  • October, 2008: Manny Legace suffers a hip injury while stepping on the red carpet placed on the ice for Sarah Palin.
  • March 1993: Brian Leetch breaks his ankle while stepping out of a cab, as did former Rangers Captain Jean Ratelle in 1972
  • April 2007: Brent Sopel throws out his back picking up a cracker from the floor
  • October 2005: Wade Belak misses the season opener after he is bitten by a spider
  • February 1999: Rich Parent is hit by an Al MacInnis slapshot in pregame warmups, suffering a "serious testicular injury."

Freak accidents happen. I believe it is irresponsible of David Poile to allow the Predators to walk into the Honda Center with only 18 skaters. The Predators finished ONE WIN behind Columbus last season - and missed the playoffs. Wouldn't it be a shame to basically give up the chance at a win by only skating 17 players against Anaheim? Especially given the fact that it is completely unneccessary?

The Milwaukee Admirals exist to provide the Predators with players. Why not use them when needed? Tell Peter Olvecky to get on a plane. "Sorry, buddy - you're not gonna play...but we need you here just in case."

Adding to my outrage today is that I am the only person that seems to think this is a problem. I asked several people in the Admirals organization last night if they thought another recall was coming. They all seemed genuinely surprised that I would even bring it up.

The foks we talk to in Nashville on a regular basis don't seem to think there's much of a problem here, either. The beat writers at the Tennessean haven't even mentioned it. (They've mentioned the injuries...but not the tenuous position it puts the roster in).  

You can feel free to disagree, too. What I would really like to know, though, is WHY NOT? Why not call somone up for the day? Are the Predators really that concerned about paying someone NHL money for ONE day? If so, why not recall Ryan Jones? He's making NHL money regardless, due to his one-way contract.

I hope this becomes a moot point. I hope all is well, and all 18 skaters are healthy. But if something happens - and there's a late scratch - I am going to hire a sky-writer to scrawl "I Told You So" above the Preds corporate officers.

Anyone wanna chip in?

Comments

 

Jensen said:

I agree completely Eric.  I remember when Legace tripped over the Sarah Palin carpet...  Stuff like that can happen and the Preds need everything chance at a win that they can get at this point.

November 5, 2009 1:52 PM
 

CreedFeed said:

I guess my only comment would be - with Belak averaging like 1 minute of ice time* over the last few games he's played, why couldn't they run with 17 skaters? :-)

(*disclaimer - the 1 minute number is not an actually calculated out average)

November 5, 2009 1:52 PM
 

Ryan Miller said:

That's an interesting counterpoint, Creed.  I mean, we've complained about how some of the young guys would only get 6 minutes of ice time over the course of the game.  One could argue that sometimes Trotz basically rolls with 17 skaters on a regular basis.

But still.....why not have the most bang possible in your arsenal?  It's not that they can't.  It's that they won't, and there's got to be a reason somewhere.

November 5, 2009 2:07 PM
 

CreedFeed said:

Agreed Ryan. It's not that they can't, it's they won't. That is what makes no sense. I can't think of any other reason why they wouldn't make this move. They've done it in the past... (I think?)

Unless they truly are trying to avoid the cost of flying someone to CA and housing them for a game? If that's the case, perhaps Nashville doesn't deserve an NHL team? hah.

November 5, 2009 2:18 PM
 

Twitter Trackbacks for Inexcuseable Roster Management - Admirals Short Shifts [sportsbubbler.com] on Topsy.com said:

Pingback from  Twitter Trackbacks for                 Inexcuseable Roster Management - Admirals Short Shifts         [sportsbubbler.com]        on Topsy.com

November 5, 2009 2:24 PM
 

StoutGuy29 said:

I'm shocked about how shocked you are that the Predators are being mismanaged

November 5, 2009 2:36 PM
 

BnaPredatorsFan said:

I totally agree.  I am in Nashville, and there is no talk of this and I can't understand it.

November 5, 2009 3:08 PM
 

jon said:

it is rather surprising that another admiral has not been called up to the NHL but im not complaining i just hope the guys that most likely wont get the call this year (maki, jessiman, rabbitt, etc.) start melding and pulling our team.

November 5, 2009 3:12 PM
 

ads fan said:

Erat made the trip to  CA and did some skating today.  If they took him they most likely think he will be ready to go again soon-- maybe Saturday in LA?  -- or maybe today if  the hangnail on his toe is healed and they really need him.    That said I agree with Eric that it doesn't make sense to take that chance.

November 5, 2009 3:58 PM
 

Johnny B said:

Speaking of injuries and whatnot, Maki has a broken leg, out 6 weeks.

November 5, 2009 4:15 PM
 

ads fan said:

Well that stinks!   -- and the AHL transaction log shows Mueller on his way back to Milwaukee.

November 5, 2009 4:40 PM
 

jon said:

Let me rephrase the players i mentioned as needing to meld and carry the team (Guite, jessiman,rabbitt, etc) hard for ryan to do anything with a broken leg. Damn i really thought that this would be a big year for him too. :(

Anyway looking at the up coming schedule there is a huge challenge on the not so distant horizon for the Ads. This mid November Texas trip. 2games vs each of the three team in texas.

In years past San Antonio was bottom feeder but they really play with alot of grit and passion and showed last year despite a poor record that they were a tough team to play. Houston is always a very detailed team that can be as dangerous as anyone out there and then there is Texas the division leader last time i looked they have many nice players and one of the better goalie pairing with Climie and Krahn.

I think the ads if they can get a little more on the same page and consistant over the next three or four games can go down south and give these guys a little bit of a hard time i think 4-1-1 on the Texas trip is how we will fare.

November 5, 2009 4:42 PM
 

Jim said:

Maybe the team could argue that even if something happened to a player right before game time, the 17 remaining skaters would work better together than adding an 18th...

November 5, 2009 5:07 PM
 

Iceman said:

Eric - 100% total over-reaction on your part.  I think a more interesting topic would be WHY do people actually think Ryan Jones is a good hockey player worthly of a one-way deal at $900,000 + this season.

This guy is a joke at that salary , he is not even close to being the Admiral's best player at this point.

November 5, 2009 9:04 PM
 

Matt said:

This year's ryan jones is not last years ryan jones i was execited to have jones back after what he did last year but so far he doesn't even seem close to the player that he was last year

November 5, 2009 9:49 PM
 

Big Tony said:

mueller belongs up here, used to see him play at Michigan state this kid can play

November 6, 2009 5:34 AM
 

Ryan Miller said:

Tough going for the Preds last night, as TO's kill them.  Unfortunately, Thuresson gets a lot of the blame for the 2nd goal against Pekka, as he fed a perfect pass to a duck at the blue line.  Poor Pekka.  His defense was subpar, and the Ducks offense capitalized when they had the chances.

Preds did have 40 shots on goal...a quarter of them from Patric Hornqvist.

Wade Belak -- 3:36 of ice time.

November 6, 2009 7:10 AM
 

Eric W. Kent said:

Iceman - I think that's easy to say since it turned out not to burn the Preds. However, I still believe it boils down to risk management.

There was absolutely no reason for the Predators to assume the risk they did.  

As for Jones, I don't think there's anyone out there that would give him that same contract today. But what can you do? Who would trade for him?

November 6, 2009 10:19 AM
 

Iceman said:

Eric - That is my point ,,, NOW you can not TRADE Ryan Jones ,, David Poile shot himself in the balls on this deal.

We will have to agree to disagree on the Preds roster , no worries for me , goal scoring is needed not another guy to seat in the pressbox wearing a nice suit .

November 6, 2009 12:41 PM
 

Eric W. Kent said:

No problem, Iceman. I'm happy to disagree. As I stated, I didn't find many people that agreed with me prior to writing the post.

Call me a ***-eyed optimist, but I still have hope for Jones.

Of course, that's more of a long-term hope. I don't know what the Preds are going to do for right now. I hope for their fans' sake they do SOMETHING.

November 6, 2009 4:17 PM

Leave a Comment

(required )  
(optional )
(required )  
Add

About Eric W. Kent

As a graduate of Marquette University's College of Communication, Eric has spent 11 of the last 14 years lending a critical eye to the Milwaukee sports scene. Prior to covering the Admirals for Short Shifts, Eric was a sportscaster for both the NBC and ABC affiliates in Grand Rapids, MI. His broadcasting career has also included stints in Milwaukee and Eau Claire, WI.

About This Blog

A blog about your Milwaukee Admirals, complete with news, analysis, and a whole lot of sarcasm. Probably the best blog ever to grace the Interweb. Seriously.

Recent Posts

Advertisement

Friends Of Admirals Short Shifts

Syndication