[UPDATE]
Thanks to Mike for tabulating the incentives. I was not going to include them because they were not considered in last season's payroll number before the season started, but it is a fine point. The incentives do bring the payroll between the $80-85MM mark.
-----------------------------------------------------------
In light of the Brewers brass asserting the Brewers have all but reached their $80-85MM payroll limit, I decided to analyze the payroll numbers a bit myself.
Something seemed a bit off to me. Milwaukee budgeted for Prince Fielder's new contract. They also loosely budgeted for the payroll increases due to the other arbitration-eligible players. Nothing has happened this offseason that the Brewers haven't projected, at least financially.
Keep in mind this projection is the "worst case scenario." It predicts Corey Hart and Rickie Weeks going to an arbitration hearing and winning their case. This should be a very conservative estimation of the 2009 Milwaukee Brewers payroll as the roster now stands.
| Jeff Suppan |
12.5 |
| Mike Cameron |
10 |
| Prince Fielder |
7.5 |
| Bill Hall |
6.8 |
| Trevor Hoffman |
6 |
| J.J. Hardy |
4.65 |
| David Riske |
4.25 |
| Jason Kendall |
5 |
| Dave Bush |
4 |
| Corey Hart |
3.8 |
| Rickie Weeks |
2.8 |
| Seth McClung |
1.66 |
| Craig Counsell |
1 |
| Jorge Julio |
0.95 |
| Todd Coffey |
0.8 |
| Ryan Braun |
0.75 |
| Carlos Villanueva |
0.41 |
| Yovani Gallardo |
0.4 |
| Manny Parra |
0.4 |
| Mike Lamb |
0.4 |
| Mike Rivera |
0.4 |
| Mitch Stetter |
0.4 |
| Tim Dillard |
0.4 |
| Tony Gwynn Jr. |
0.4 |
| Trot Nixon |
0.4 |
Incentives
|
5.85
|
| TOTAL |
81.92 |
(Prince Fielder's salary includes his $1MM signing bonus.)
Even with Corey and Rickie winning their arbitration cases, the Brewers still have about $4.5MM to play with before entering the 2009 season. Mark Attanasio has even mentioned an $85MM payroll cap, which would give Doug Melvin ~$9.5MM to allocate towards the starting rotation.
It seems odd that Mark Attanasio and Doug Melvin would firmly assert that the Brewers payroll is at $80-85MM when it clearly is below the number.
One explanation could be that the payroll includes the salaries for the coaches, GMs, and owners. That does not make much sense, however. Why would the payroll, which is traditionally tabulated by adding players' contracts, suddenly include the management? This seems unreasonable.
Another explanation could be that my calculations are off. I am willing to admit that. Can anyone see where my numbers may be off?
The Brewers could also be preparing for a 2009 season that will be played amidst a severe economic downturn. Could they simply be posing a higher payroll to protect against not raking in as much cash as projected?
If none of those are the answer, could the Brewers simply be posturing? Is Doug Melvin lurking in the shadows when it comes to deals with Braden Looper or Jon Garland, only to swoop in at the last second to try to score a free agent bargain at the deadline?
That is all I have. The numbers seem to not support the claims the Brewers front office has been asserting. What do you think?