JJ Hardy sent to Minnesota for Carlos Gomez

It didn't take long for Doug Melvin to start making moves.  Just two days after the World Series finished, the Brewers GM started the off season by trading shortstop JJ Hardy for speedy center fielder, Carlos Gomez.

It's not the sexiest of trades and I'm sure fans are going to go after Melvin for not chasing down one of the Twins arms in this deal, but let's be honest here.  JJ destroyed his trade value in 2009, and if it wasn't for a technicality that added an extra arbitration year to his contract, the former Brewers' starting shortstop wouldn't have garnered much of anything.  Instead the Brewers were able to pick up a young athletic center fielder who is under their control for the next four years.

Gomez is definitely a solid outfielder, but his offense leaves much to be desired, at least for the moment.  In parts of three seasons in the bigs, Gomez is hitting .246/.292/.346 with 59 SBs and 21 CS.  There's no point in discussing the homerun numbers.  That's just not his game.   But can the Brewers really afford to have a guy with a sub-.300 OBP at the top of their line-up?  Absolutely not, but Gomez's minor league numbers indicate he could become good enough.  If Gomez can hit .280+ and utilize his speed a little more, he is the perfect fit for the Brewers. 

And by perfect, I mean cheap.  The Brewers are struggling to pay for their big players, and in order to keep them around for a little bit longer before rebuilding, they need to find ways to save money.  By saying goodbye to Mike Cameron, the Brewers are saving up to $9M.  An additional $4M is gained by shedding JJ's contract. This money can be used to try and swoon a starter off the slim free agent market or pick up the contract of a pitcher on the trade market. 

So don't go after Doug just yet.  This is an excellent precursor to a winter that should be filled with a frenzy of moves.

Comments

 

Adam said:

It is a great deal, players often get better when they go from the American League to the National League, and now Weeks doesn't have to lead off anymore.

November 6, 2009 12:21 PM
 

Jess said:

I think we could look at it this way, too; the Twins probably kept him in the minors if they'd had the choice. With the Brewers, he'd have been in AAA last year and, at most, a call-up. At 24, we can imagine him as a guy who is coming up from triple-A, and look at him as a rookie. Is the OBP bad because of baserunning mistakes, similar to what we saw in the NLDS from the Twins?

November 6, 2009 1:02 PM
 

TW said:

As a Brewer fan in Minnesota, I can say Gomez is an exciting player. Tons of speed. Great outfielder. But he swings at every pitch. No plate discipline. Strikes out a lot while looking foolish. But he can bunt his way on like nobody's business. If he can learn to put the ball in play, take more pitches and utilize his speed, he could be a great leadoff man.

The problem is, if the Twins, a small-ball team built on doing those things and doing them well, couldn't teach him to do it, how can the all-or-nothing, free swinging Brewers do it, with a manager that never bunts?

November 6, 2009 1:12 PM
 

Chris said:

Too bad his speed won't be utilized when you have Ken "Moneyball" Macha in the dugout.

November 6, 2009 1:16 PM
 

Jason said:

@Jess - OBP has nothing to do with baserunning mistakes.

I like this move.  Freeing up some cash while upgrading the future of CF.

November 6, 2009 2:25 PM
 

Brew Town Boozer said:

I like the move.  It frees up 13M in salary and gives a player with good upside.  In my opinion, this move will benefit the Brewers in retaining a good defensive 2B, but allows Weeks to hit behind Fielder (provided we get the same Rickie as when he left).  Now McGehee can hit 2nd, where he should have been in '09.   This move helps the Crew, especially if Gomez can hit.  He's 24 and on his 3rd MLB team, maybe that alone flips a switch.

November 6, 2009 2:52 PM
 

TheWiscSportsNut2 said:

There were some comparing Gomez to a poor man's Jose Reyes...Good move for the Twins as well getting a former All Star SS to go with Mauer, Morneau and Span...  

November 6, 2009 3:04 PM
 

Lidocaine said:

Doug Melvin has already come out and said Rickie Weeks is still the leadoff hitter and Gomez will hit at the bottom of the lineup.

November 6, 2009 5:44 PM
 

Brew Town Boozer said:

I saw that after my post.  I guess it is more of my opinion.  I guess I thought Escobar was going to hit low in the order as well.   I can't see these two hitting back to back, so one would have to assume that Escobar is the #2 hitter then?  

Weeks

Escobar

Braun

Fielder

McGehee

Hart

Gomez

Catcher

SP

Obviously many move left to be made, just speculating that if Gomez isn't the leadoff hitter, then Escobar is the #2 hitter.

November 6, 2009 8:40 PM
 

naughtypartsoozingwithpus said:

This is a great move for the Brewers. It fills a need for centerfield, also it gives the brewers options at the top of the order, and with Hardy gone we no longer have a logjam in the infield.

Don't be surprised if Gomez starts to be a good hitter because when you get a fresh start with a team that actually wants you it can do wonders ask Tony Gwynn JR

November 7, 2009 11:31 AM
 

Dan K. said:

finally traded Hardy after that garbage year. Should've got another pitcher though

November 8, 2009 8:46 PM

Leave a Comment

(required )  
(optional )
(required )  
Add

About This Blog

Bernie's Crew is a Milwaukee Brewers blog that addresses everything concerning the Brewers. It discusses major league news, minor league news, and big news around Major League Baseball as a whole. It is a community where Brewers fans can let their voice and opinions be heard. If you have any comments or questions, email me at berniescrew@gmail.com.

Recent Posts

Advertisement

Additional Sites

Syndication