Corey Hart should be on the trading block

"GM Doug Melvin told me any talk of the Brewers shopping RF Corey Hart is pure nonsense," Tom Haudricourt (twitter)

"The two clubs that called the Brewers on the weekend to see if Milwaukee really was making Corey Hart available heard that he is not on the block." Ken Rosenthal

I know there need to be some gamesmanship when it comes to making trades, but Doug Melvin is going a little overboard.  Despite his faults and struggles, Corey Hart is a valuable ball player and what he adds to the Brewers shouldn't be overlooked.  But he doesn't do anything that isn't replaceable.  The Brewers farm system produces guys with bats and no position, so anyone occupying a corner outfield spot is expendable.

The only thing that can force Melvin to hold on to Hart so tightly is that he believes that Hart will be the starting center fielder in 2010.  Mike Cameron has had a career year so far in 2009, and it won't make sense to pay for that production in 2010 when Cameron will be 37-years-old.

Hart has to be attractive to teams (not a surprise if clubs are calling on him).  He's in his prime, has flashes of power and the speed to cover ground in the outfield and swipe bases.  Also, he's still cheap for another couple seasons.  He's a really nice piece in a trade since he can be paired with a good prospect.  It also means that the Brewers should get a decent return.  They aren't in a position where they need to trade Hart, but they can trade Hart is the right package comes along.  It's good to be in that kind of position and the Brewers should take advantage of it if they have the oppotunity.

Comments

 

John Grossbard said:

Agreed. If the right package comes along, Hart should be traded. There are few untouchables on this team.

I also believe that Hardy is a better trade target for teams such as the Red Sox, who are loaded with pitching and need a solid SS. I love Hardy, but I would love talented pitchers even more.

June 4, 2009 5:49 PM
 

dphill said:

This is such a delicate thing to predict. Look at Manny Parra...who'd have thought he'd blow up? Look around the league and you always see some young pitcher just losing it...how about Dontrelle, Carmona, Nolasco or even the Barry Zito's of the world. This assumption that we can just turn JJ and/or Hart into the next John Lester or Yovani is really really risky. I agre that Hart's skills are more replaceable than JJ's, but he's very good value for his pricetag for 2009 anyway.
June 6, 2009 5:55 AM
 

RobinYountFan said:

I say wait until the Glavine thing plays out - If the Brewers sign him, then keep Corey Hart. If they don't sign him, then trade Corey Hart for somebody along the lines of Randy Wolf or Cliff Lee. In my honest opinion, I think that Glavine would be the piece of the puzzle thats missing. He'd be like the acquisition of Don Sutton in 1982, and could very easily get another ring. J.J. should not be traded because he is a dynomite SS, (not as good as Robin) and the Brewers cannot afford to lose his glove in the infield.
June 7, 2009 10:06 PM
 

MilwaukeeMan said:

What the team need is a left hander in the rotation...Hardy and Hart both high value trade material but I agree that Hardy's defensive prowess would be missed more than Corey's. Both players bats are somewhat cold right now but that is not to say that they will not wake up. Let's not forget that we do have a highy praised shortstop in waiting by the name of Escobar in AAA. Bring him up and get him a big league feel at 2nd, see if that blossoms and then decide if Hardy can be traded for a lefty starter with another prospect or 2. We have the ability to move players around but have all RHP is not a good thing when it comes to teams loaded with left handed bats like the Cardinals.
June 16, 2009 10:45 AM
 

DoItForUek said:

Think anyone wants a beat up Ricky Weeks to use next season? JK. Hardy at SS, Escobar to 2B, McGeHee/Counsel 2B. Gamel at 3B. Trade Hart to the South Siders for Gavin Floyd and Scotty Pod. Podsednik plays CF between Catalanatto/?? and Braun. Floyd takes spot in rotation in place of whoever isn't named Yovani Gallardo. Possibly win division, if not, you're still set for next year. /thread
July 13, 2009 1:09 AM

Leave a Comment

(required )  
(optional )
(required )  
Add