December 2008 - Posts

  • Questionable whether Collins deserves Pro Bowl

    Maybe I'm being a Grinch this holiday season, but I really think it's debatable whether Nick Collins deserves the Pro Bowl spot to which he was named last week.

    And he's a starter? There's got to be another safety out there somewhere in the NFC that's more worthy than Collins.

    Now I'll admit, I can't cite many statistics in defense of this argument. I don't have the time or the resources to review game film or even name a more worthy candidate, but my instinct tells me Collins shouldn't be heading to Hawaii.

    Five interceptions does not a Pro Bowler make. Of course, that's the thing that stands out most about Collins. He's tied for the NFC lead in interceptions with five. And three of them have gone for touchdowns, which I'll admit is amazing.

    But he is not a consistent player. Collins looks to make the big play, he looks to jump in front of passes, and then gets burned by a savvy quarterback looking to exploit on a defense's miscues.

    Collins is guilty of commiting to a player running an underneath route while looking to make one of those ever-impressive interceptions. Meanwhile, there's a player running right by him over the top for a catch over the middle of the field.

    And I feel like I'm starting to become a broken record, but Collins is a below average tackler. In the loss to the Houston Texans for example, Collins missed a tackle on reception down the center of the field. The receiver brushed Collins off and easily waltzed into the endzone.

    I guess I expect more out of a safety. I expect a Pro Bowl starting caliber safety to create turnovers but not allow as many touchdowns as he himself makes. I hope he's a sure tackler too. When was the last time you saw a Nick Collins tackle and said, "Ouch." Never?

    Granted, I'm glad Collins has made such strides this season. He's had his best season in a Packers' uniform and hopefully he'll only improve from here on out. And he's been durable too. He's the only safety on the Packers who's been reliable week after week.

    But I'm looking for more consistency.

    Those three touchdowns sure are impressive, though. Maybe I am just being a Grinch. Excuse me while I go buy some lumps of coal as Christmas presents.

  • Future Packer Sherrod Martin?

    The Green Bay Packers game is still a day away, but today at Railbird Central we give you something to watch today while tying it into the Packers. Consider it a little NFL Draft preview.

    The only bowl game today is the New Orleans Bowl that pits the Sun Belt champions Troy against Southern Mississippi, winners of four straight.

    It should be a competitive and underrated game that won't register on a lot of fans' radars, but it should. The main storyline will be the Golden Eagle offense against the Trojan defense, but each club has enough stars on each side of the ball to make things interesting.

    Southern Mississippi has future NFL prospects at all the skill positions.

    "Southern Miss might have the top QB-RB-WR combination of any non-BCS team," writes Pete Fiutak of CollegeFootballNews.com, "or it’s at least among the best with (Austin Davis sic)Young, (Damion) Fletcher and (DeAndre) Brown all able to carry the offense if needed."

    It'll be up to Troy safety Sherrod Martin (#6 pictured at right) and the rest of the Trojan defense to contain the talented trio that has gotten better as the season has gone on.

    Martin lines up at safety for the Trojans but is listed as number six rated cornerback in the 2009 draft class by Scott Wright's NFL Draft Countdown. The senior has earned a Senior Bowl invite to prove his worth to NFL clubs.

    The Green Bay Packers supposedly have a group of talented safeties if they can stay healthy. Led by Pro Bowler Nick Collins, the group also includes Atari Bigby, Aaron Rouse and Charlie Peprah, none of whom stayed very healthy this year.

    As for cornerbacks, the Packers have pretty good depth there as well. But they could use some help if Al Harris gets traded this offseason like he predicts.

    The secondary is far from one of the Packers' biggest concerns, but watching Martin, who will definitely be playing on Sundays next season, will be worth it.
     

  • Future Packer Brandon Pearce?

    The Green Bay Packers game is still two days away, but on Saturdays here at Railbird Central we give you something to watch today while tying it into the Packers. Consider it a little NFL Draft preview.

    Bowl season starts today with an intriguing matchup. The first ever St. Petersburg Bowl will see Memphis taking on the South Florida in what is practically a home game for the Bulls.

    The game could be a blowout. Some handicappers (myself included) are pegging USF to run away with the game. But if Memphis can stay in the game, it will at least in part be due to tackle Brandon Pearce.

    Pearce is Memphis' best pro prospect according to Russ Lande in the most recent issue of the Sporting News. In fact, South Florida's best pro prospect is same guy Pearce will be lining up across from, George Selvie.

    Right now it's looking like Selvie will most likely declare for the NFL draft after his junior season. And if he does, he'll most likely be a sure fire first round draft pick.

    Pearce, on the other hand, is no where near first round material. He's the 26th ranked senior tackle in this year's draft class according to Scott Wright at NFLDraftCountdown.com. But his matchup today against Selvie will be a huge measuring stick for how good Pearce actually is.

    "George Selvie continues to be the headliner even if his numbers plummeted from a year ago," writes Richard Cirminiello of CollegeFootballNews.com. "A dynamite athlete, who could leave early for the NFL following the game, he has the explosive speed to change the tenor of a game. He’ll be locked up with Brandon Pearce, Memphis’ best blocker and a first team All-Conference USA selection."

    Pearce is a little on the small side for an NFL tackle. At 290 lbs., he needs to add some weight to his frame, which is a decent 6-6.

    Seriously folks, watch this matchup. As you know, the Packers have their own injury and age issues at both tackle positions. If Pearce gets dominated by Selvie, you'll know this is a guy the Packers should stay away from. But if he can hold his own and neutralize Selvie's effectiveness, Pearce could be an underrated prospect.

    By the same token, keep tabs on Selvie too. Everybody and their brother knows the Packers need an impact defensive end perhaps more than at any other position on the team. The Packers are staring at a top-10 pick in the draft come April, and they could be in a good position to draft a guy like Selvie.

    The game starts at 3:30 p.m. CST on ESPN2 today.

  • Porter finds his way onto Packers roster after trying times

    There was a time period in cornerback Joe Porter's life that was pretty tough.

    After signing with the New Orleans Saints as an undrafted free agent last season, he was cut during training camp when teams had to trim their rosters down to 75 players. It wasn't until that following November that Porter was signed to the Green Bay Packers' practice squad.

    Between August and November of 2007, Porter was jobless. He had a couple of tryouts with NFL teams, one with the Packers and the other with the Washington Redskins. He even had a couple of tryouts with Arena League teams.

    But while he was bouncing around the country from tryout to  tryout, he didn't exactly have a lot of money. He asked his parents for a little bit of income and even had a hard time paying for food while he was on the road during those tryouts.

    "It definitely tests your character and your work ethic to see if you're going to stay with it and keep going at it," said Porter, "but it was really difficult to say the least."

    And as tough as that time period was in his life, there was one that was even tougher.

    After finishing the 2007 season on the Packers' practice squad, Porter was signed to a new contract to compete for a roster spot during the upcoming 2008 training camp. It was during training camp that Porter had to deal with the death of his father all while trying to keep the dream alive of becoming an NFL player.

    Just two days after the Packers' first preseason game of the season on Monday Night Football against the Cincinnati Bengals and just two days before the team would have to leave on a cross country trip to take on the San Francisco 49ers, Porter was sleeping in his St. Norbert College dormitory bed just like the rest of the players.

    "They sent one of the security guards to my room to wake me up and told me to call my family," said Porter. "I was preparing for the worst."

    Having battled through stage four lung cancer, his father passed away later that day, but not before Porter got a chance to say goodbye to him.

    "It was tough having to get up and go to practice the next morning and try to block it out and try to deal with it," said Porter. "And it happened so soon. But my family was there for me, and my team was definitely there for me."

    Times were tough, but Porter overcame adversity and was again signed to Green Bay's practice squad after having been released during training camp.

    Porter could have sulked. He could have stagnated having been on just the practice squad for a second consecutive season.

    After all, the Packers decided to keep linebacker Nick Barnett on the active roster for three weeks after his season ending knee injury instead of making a roster move. Porter could have felt unappreciated knowing that he was sitting on the practice squad when there was a spot available on the 53-man roster and the Packers decided not to fill it.

    "Nick is a linebacker," said Porter," and I thought they would probably activate the guy on the practice squad at his position or maybe find somebody else. I understand from their perspective, it is a business, and they have to do what's right for the franchise. So I didn't take it personally at all.

    Then came Monday December 1 when Porter was finally elevated to the Packers' 53-man roster, and he was able to move out of the team's auxillary locker room and into the main locker room.

    "It was euphoria," said Porter. "Everything I had worked for up to that point, it had finally happened. I was actually a little breathless. When it finally happened, I was just so excited and happy. My mother was crying. I was very excited."

    Porter has been on the 53-man roster for the past two games but has yet to be active on game day. Maybe his time is coming.

    He has the speed. Porter was the Big East conference champion in the 200-meter sprint in 2006 and the Rutgers school record holder, but he knows he's not just track star.

    "A lot of guys see me, they look at my experience and my size and say, 'He's just a speed guy,'" said Porter. "But then I go run down there and knock somebody's head off."

    With the Packers out of the playoff chase, Porter just might get his chance to be active in the last couple weeks of the season. And there's a shot that he'll overcome adversity once again.

    This article was written after a Railbird Central exclusive interview with Joe Porter.

  • All I want for Christmas is Haynesworth and Peppers

    I definitely won't get my wish for Christmas because free agency doesn't start until after the Super Bowl, but I like what Jay Sorgi of the Packers Radio Network is thinking.

    After a season in which the Packers are guaranteed of a losing record, it's time to get out and get active in free agency. That hasn't exactly been general manager Ted Thompson's M.O., but after a losing season, it's got to be.

    After the Packers finished Mike Sherman's last season at 4-12, Thompson got active in free agency by signing Charles Woodson and Ryan Pickett.  He didn't exactly break the bank, but they were two good offseason acquisitions.

    If the Packers would go after both Julius Peppers and Albert Haynesworth in free agency, is there any doubt that this team would be much improved next season? The defense would be as stout as any in the NFL.

    The secondary, of course, is in good shape as evidenced by two starters just elected to the Pro Bowl announced yesterday. As for the linebackers, there's reason for concern there, but there's also some hope if Peppers and Haynesworth come aboard.

    "Having Albert Haynesworth next to Peppers, Cullen Jenkins and Aaron Kampman might not only allow for the line to no longer get gashed by Smash and Dash of Tennessee and Adrian Peterson of Minnesota, but perhaps we might not be screaming and ranting about no production by A.J. Hawk," writes Sorgi.

    "When he's not tied up by blockers, he can actually make plays."

    Likewise, the Packers won't have to worry about any 2009 draft choice having to make an impact right away. The Packers could put off a year to draft along the defensive line and instead worry about drafting linebackers and offensive linemen instead.

    There's plenty of good offensive skill players already on the team. That's not what needs to be improved in the offseason.

    So yeah, the Packers will probably have to pay through their teeth to get both Peppers and Haynesworth. But the reward will be worth the investment. By going out and getting two defensive linemen, they hedge their bet if one of them happens to be a bust.

    The Packers can actually do it too. They've been practicing fiscal responsibility for years. They're among the NFL leaders for the most salary cap space.

    And doing things like giving quarterback Aaron Rodgers a front loaded contract looks even better. It gives the Packers even more wiggle room next year.

    If the Packers want to win now in the NFL, they had better get active in free agency. This team is not going to improve solely through the draft.

More Posts « Previous page - Next page »

About This Blog

This is the place for those of you who can't get enough Green Bay Packers news! Updates will be provided frequently from the view of a "railbird." We go to the practices and scan the local media so you don't have to.

Milwaukee Magazine says, "Insightful and newsy, Brian Carriveau’s work could be mistaken for beat reporting instead of blogging. His coverage of the team’s practices is virtually unprecedented."

For comments, questions and media inquiries, please e-mail carriveau@uwalumni.com

Recent Posts

Advertisement

Packers Daily Links

Syndication