Packers coaches ignore preseason play

Some might say the relevance of this column is past, and that may be so. It also might be long overdue.

Based upon roster cuts and personnel decisions made by the coaching staff, it's obvious that the Green Bay Packers don't care about preseason football games. How else can one explain the apathy toward perhaps the three best individual performances of the '09 preseason.

Take Tyrell Sutton for example (yes, I'm beating a horse that's not only dead, it's rotten and decaying as well). He was the Packers leading rusher during the preseason, gaining nearly 100 more yards than the next closest player. He also had a 4.8 yard average per carry, best on the team among running backs.

Fans know the story by now. Sutton is cut and eventually signed by the Carolina Panthers. Meanwhile, the Packers have an ineffective running game, are injury-riddled at the position and have just signed an aging Ahman Green whose best years are behind him.

I'm not naive enough to think that Sutton was the cure for all that ails the Packer defense. But I think even the most ardent supporters of the Mike McCarthy/Ted Thompson regime would rather have seen a rookie with potential and fresh legs like Sutton rather than a veteran past his prime like Green.

Sutton is far from the only case study. Also released on the final day of roster cutdowns was safety Anthony Smith at another position where the Packers have had their fair share of troubles.

Given the injury to Atari Bigby, hindsight is 20/20. But combined with the release of Aaron Rouse, Smith would have proven to be a more capable backup at safety than either Derrick Martin or Matt Giordano, both of whom have had to learn the Packers' defense after training camp.

Smith was the only free agent of any significance signed this offseason and could have figured into the Packers' equation on defense. Considering the contract status of Nick Collins, the injury situation regarding Bigby and the below average histories of Jarrett Bush, Martin and Giordano, Smith could have lent at least a modicum of stability at safety.

He, too, performed well during the preseason. One of only two players on the team with at least two interceptions during preseason play, Smith also tallied a sack on a safety blitz and also led the team in passes defensed to boot.

And finally for the player still on the Packers' roster but with no more than a special teams role, Desmond Bishop. Despite a lack of impact plays from the inside linebacker position, Bishop still rusts away on the bench.

He was the team's leading tackler in the preseason but also tallied a sack, two interceptions, a forced fumble, two fumble recoveries and two passes defended. With those kinds of stats Bishop probably had the best overall preseason of any single player on the Packers' roster.

Now in Bishop's third season as a pro, it's unclear whether the coaching staff is holding him back due to deficiencies from seasons past or problems seen during practice. Either way, Bishop did everything in his power to prove himself on the field of play.

Shouldn't performance during game situations be the number one evaluation tool? If not, shouldn't it at least rank near the top? In regards to the Packers, it appears not.

 

 

Comments

 

IronMan said:

The offensive line played well in the preseason too.... Preseason = meaningless.
October 22, 2009 5:29 PM
 

Brian Carriveau said:

Touche.

October 22, 2009 5:32 PM
 

Twitter Trackbacks for Packers coaches ignore preseason play - Railbird Central [sportsbubbler.com] on Topsy.com said:

Pingback from  Twitter Trackbacks for                 Packers coaches ignore preseason play - Railbird Central         [sportsbubbler.com]        on Topsy.com

October 22, 2009 5:39 PM
 

uberVU - social comments said:

This post was mentioned on Twitter by BrianCarriveau: New Railbird Central article: #Packers coaches ignore preseason play: http://bit.ly/2lme4N #NFL

October 22, 2009 5:59 PM
 

Asshalo said:

I'm still irritated by having three FBs. Could have used that spot for Smith or Rouse now that Chillar is our best option for Bigby's backup. This video could apply to any player who should be on the roster in place of sutton: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzV9_lQsnpA&feature=related
October 22, 2009 6:37 PM
 

jeremiah said:

yeah, alot of concerning, and confusing decisions made this pre season....
October 22, 2009 6:50 PM
 

Adam said:

It is frustrating to the Packers sign Green when they could have had fresh legs in Sutton.  Who knows, maybe he could have been Ryan Grant '07 part duex.  Either way he isn't getting any action down in Carolina and Jonathan Stewart has been banged up.

Preseason is pretty meaningless in my mind.  Look how great the offense looked compared to now.  And the defense was swarming the quarterback and now really lack a pass rush.  Many teams run very vanilla schemes in the preseason and I think the Packers took advantage of that.  We all have to remember the Lions went 4-0 last year in preseason.  That sums it up right there.

October 23, 2009 11:02 AM
 

Erik said:

I'm with Ironman on this one.  The preseason for the Packers (and a lot of teams over the years) have shown that the preseason actually does not matter and it is probably a good idea for coaches to largely ignore stat sheets that come out of them.

October 23, 2009 11:22 AM
 

Franklin Hillside said:

"I'm beating a horse that's not only dead, it's rotten and decaying as well" -Lol.
October 23, 2009 2:04 PM

Leave a Comment

(required )  
(optional )
(required )  
Add

About This Blog

This is the place for those of you who can't get enough Green Bay Packers news! Updates will be provided frequently from the view of a "railbird." We go to the practices and scan the local media so you don't have to.

Milwaukee Magazine says, "Insightful and newsy, Brian Carriveau’s work could be mistaken for beat reporting instead of blogging. His coverage of the team’s practices is virtually unprecedented."

For comments, questions and media inquiries, please e-mail carriveau@uwalumni.com

Recent Posts

Advertisement

Packers Daily Links

Syndication