Packers could fall victim to the Pro Bowl conundrum

A topic that's been brought up many times is that of the decisions the Green Bay Packers have to make about extending the contracts of players currently on their roster before the end of the season such that the money doesn't have to be prorated over future salary caps.

There's nearly 10 players headed into free agency this upcoming offseason, so there's plenty of players to choose from when deciding who to extend before the end of the year and who can wait.

The player the Packers need the most also happens to be the same player who will most likely command the most money on the open market, safety Nick Collins.

Of course, the future of the collective bargaining agreement will play a huge role in Collins' future as well. If the CBA is extended, Collins will become an unrestricted free agent. If the two sides can't come to an agreement, the safety will become an unrestricted free agent severely limiting who or who he can't sign with.

Collins has had a a good season with the Packers, but not exactly what some would characterize as great. He's been reliable. He's made the occassional interception, has been a solid tackler and has rarely gotten beat in coverage. But he also hasn't been the big time playmaker that he was a year ago when he returned three interceptions for touchdowns.

For his effort, Collins was awarded a Pro Bowl nomination a year ago and deservedly so. The problem with the Pro Bowl, however, is once you're voted in, those players tend to get voted in year after year on name recognition whether or not they deserve it.

There's nearly half a season left in 2009, and Collins may well have a huge second half with several turnovers generated. It's hard to see into the future and predict what kind of season he'll have. But based upon his performance so far, I wouldn't exactly call it Pro Bowl material.

Regardless, there's a fairly decent chance that Collins will be elected to the Pro Bowl once again based upon historical precedent. And if Collins goes to the Pro Bowl once again, he'll come to the bargaining table with even more ammunition.

The Packers are in a tough situation. Beyond Collins and Atari Bigby, there isn't a single safety on the roster that can be trusted. And it would be extremely risky to count on a rookie to fill such a role next season.

They nearly have to re-sign Collins whether or not the CBA is extended. If the CBA is extended, which is probably the most likely scenario, and Collins makes the Pro Bowl, he'll be asking to be one of the top paid safeties in the entire NFL even if he may not be, thanks in part to the ridiculous Pro Bowl precedent. And Cullen Jenkins thought he was handcuffed a few weeks ago? How about the Packers organization?

Comments

 

Twitter Trackbacks for Packers could fall victim to the Pro Bowl conundrum - Railbird Central [sportsbubbler.com] on Topsy.com said:

Pingback from  Twitter Trackbacks for                 Packers could fall victim to the Pro Bowl conundrum - Railbird Central         [sportsbubbler.com]        on Topsy.com

November 20, 2009 12:54 PM
 

uberVU - social comments said:

This post was mentioned on Twitter by BrianCarriveau: New Railbird Central article: #Packers could fall victim to the Pro Bowl conundrum: http://bit.ly/5ZbCAU

November 20, 2009 1:46 PM
 

retiredgrampa said:

Collins has the team by the short hair. They have no one to replace him even though he is not presently a head-liner. They will have a tough time paying him what he wants but TT has not drafted anyone who can fill in. So they're stuck. We've got to hope that there's enough cap space to keep most of the others waiting in line.
November 20, 2009 7:27 PM
 

madman said:

I think that the Packers almost have to pay him. Ted's "build from within and reward your own" philosophy will become known simply as "Ted's just cheap and hurts his team," if he doesn't open the wallet for one of their own.

November 20, 2009 9:28 PM
 

bryce said:

That last interception led to a TD.  I say resign him...

November 22, 2009 2:37 PM
 

PackersRS said:

Wow. So much hate on Collins... Did I stumbled on the wrong site? Nick Collins has been better than he was last year, as he hasn't given up any big play. He has made less big plays, but IMO enough to warrant a pro-bowl berth. And about the Packers being held hostage, that's not true. Jarrett Bush and Brady Poppinga are helding us hostage with their salary. Cut them and give the money to Collins. Everybody wins.
November 22, 2009 6:38 PM

Leave a Comment

(required )  
(optional )
(required )  
Add

About This Blog

This is the place for those of you who can't get enough Green Bay Packers news! Updates will be provided frequently from the view of a "railbird." We go to the practices and scan the local media so you don't have to.

Milwaukee Magazine says, "Insightful and newsy, Brian Carriveau’s work could be mistaken for beat reporting instead of blogging. His coverage of the team’s practices is virtually unprecedented."

For comments, questions and media inquiries, please e-mail carriveau@uwalumni.com

Recent Posts

Advertisement

Packers Daily Links

Syndication