This is the official Guru vs. Baumer thread

thebaumer:

CollegeFootballGuru:

thebaumer:

Care to compare TT's number of passes and his yardage to other SEC greats?

 

Tell me how lower yardage than other SEC greats proves he is a POOR passer?  

I never said he was a GREAT passer.  Way to try to put words in my mouth.  Comparing his yardage to other SEC greats would not be relevant to our discussion at all.  All I said is that he wasn't POOR.  Comparing his numbers to other greats or showing that he didn't finish a certain statistic in the top 10% or top 20% of others doesn't prove anything.  Couldn't there be 10 great passers?  Couldn't there be 20 great passers?  Couldn't there be 30 great passers?   Tim Tebow could throw for a completion percentage of over 75% and, statistically speaking, could still be rank #11 in the SEC if he had 10 better passers.  Would that make him a POOR passer?  Owned. 

 

I doubt it can be explained to you in a way that you will accept.

thebaumer:

CollegeFootballGuru:

 

thebaumer:

When the stat presented doesn't favor you, you argue other things.

 

LOL.  I feel honored.  You state that I can't address my Tim Tebow points with stats.  But then you use my approach, mimic me actually, and attempt to bring up stats to address your points.  

Your'e welcome.  LOL.

Trying to break out the old material i see. Never said you can't use stats. Fail.

LOL.  

I've shown that Tim Tebow has good completion percentages.

I've shown that Tim Tebow has high numbers of touchdown PASSES.

I've shown that Tim Tebow has low numbers of interceptions (definition = low number of errant PASSES)

I've shown that Tim Tebow has high PASSER ratings.

AND 

now you show that Tim Tebow's total passing yards don't rank up there with the SEC greats and think you have proved something?

thebaumer:

mediocre passing completion rate

Mediocre or poor?

thebaumer:

his poor yardage

LOL

thebaumer:

the types of passes

LOL.  You mean how he teleports the ball to the reciever's hands?

thebaumer:

the scout's evals, my own eyes

thebaumer:

etc...and you have a poor passer

LOL.

thebaumer:

Guy can't even pass as good as Leak.