Either this is a massive FAIL on Melvin's part, or Hardy's value had plummeted more than we realized.

I caught it and I was surprised to hear him say it, although I agree with him. It's been my feeling all along that MN QB #4 did not want to be in Green Bay anymore, and that's part of the reason why I will never be able to forgive him for any of this. If he were literally run out of town it would be a different story.

Agreed. However, like some of the commenters said on that post, if it's a Looper-esque deal I'd be in favor of it. If it's a Suppan type deal, absolutely not.

[quote user="Creepy"] remember the old days.  [/quote] The old days never happened as far as I'm concerned. The man is dead to me, and should be dead to any Packer fan after the events of the past 2 years. He turned his back on all of us, and to do anything but boo him mercilessly would be telling him that all is forgiven. ...

Robertj, I am surprised/disappointed to see that you are a Favre sympathizer. You seem like a reasonably intelligent guy from your posts on the Brewers board. I guess I was wrong!

[quote user="Rnay"] [HAAAA!!!!!!!!! Sportsmanship?!?!?! SPORTSMANSHIP!!!! First of all, boo'ing for a rival team is not bad sportsmanship. You're telling me you wouldn't let your child Boo at a Packer game when the Bears come onto the field? Wow, talk about a strict parent. So is it good sportsmanship to retire.  Then ...

[quote user="Einsteinhood"] I do not want to keep unloading the system for 1 year rentals of pitchers, no matter how good they are. That is how you end up in situations like this year and I do not want to see repeats of that. [/quote] Are you blaming the LaPorta/Sabathia trade for the Brewers' 2009 struggles? I don't see the ...

I wish nothing but the worst things on that man, and anybody that says he deserves any sort of respect whatsoever from anybody.

[quote user="Reg Dunlop"] [quote user="StallisTim"] [quote user="Reg Dunlop"] Never want to see his number retired at this point. Additionally, I would like to see his election to the Packer HOF achieved with the same decisiveness and over a similar period of time as his annual indecision about ...

[quote user="Reg Dunlop"] Never want to see his number retired at this point. Additionally, I would like to see his election to the Packer HOF achieved with the same decisiveness and over a similar period of time as his annual indecision about whether to return and play. I suppose something along the lines of 6 or 7 ...